Car Maintenance Plan vs Service Plan: Which is Better for You?

  • By: Jose Whitmore
  • Date: May 20, 2023
  • Time to read: 11 min.

A car maintenance plan covers routine inspections, repairs and replacement of parts that wear out with time. In contrast, a service plan covers scheduled services and maintenance required by the manufacturer.

Car owners need to understand the differences between these plans to make informed decisions about which one to choose. Regular maintenance of a vehicle is crucial in securing its longevity and reducing unexpected breakdowns. Car maintenance plans and service plans are two options that car owners can consider.

While both plans aim to keep the car in good condition, they have their differences. Car maintenance plans generally cover routine services like oil changes, tire changes, brake checks and inspection of belts and hoses. On the other hand, a service plan covers services recommended by the manufacturer and includes maintenance like changing filters, flushing fluids and tune-ups. Therefore, car owners should assess their needs and vehicle usage to determine the most appropriate plan for them. This article will explore the differences between car maintenance plans and service plans to help car owners make informed decisions.

Understanding Car Maintenance Plans

Definition And Details Of Car Maintenance Plans

Car maintenance plans are designed to keep your vehicle in tip-top shape. They typically cover regular maintenance tasks and repairs, and could include oil changes, tire rotations, brake inspections, and more. These plans are usually paid for through a monthly or yearly fee, and can be a great way to ensure that your vehicle stays in good condition without having to worry about unexpected costs.

Coverage And Benefits Of Car Maintenance Plans

The coverage and benefits of car maintenance plans can vary depending on the provider. However, some of the most common services covered include oil changes, tire rotations, battery replacement, and brake inspections. Other benefits may include roadside assistance, discounts on repairs, and priority service.

In addition, many plans offer flexible payment options, making them an affordable way to care for your car.

Factors To Consider When Choosing A Car Maintenance Plan

Before choosing a car maintenance plan, it’s important to consider a few key factors. These may include:

  • The age and condition of your vehicle: Older, high-mileage cars may require more maintenance than newer models, so you’ll need to choose a plan that meets your needs.
  • The types of services covered: Make sure the plan covers the services and repairs that you expect to need.
  • The cost: Compare prices and payment options to find a plan that is affordable for you.
  • The reputation of the provider: Check reviews and ratings of the provider to ensure that they have a good reputation for quality service.

Example Of Popular Car Maintenance Plans In The Market

Here are a few examples of popular car maintenance plans:

  • Toyotacare: This plan is offered by toyota and includes 2 years or 25,000 miles of complimentary maintenance, as well as roadside assistance.
  • Bmw ultimate care: Bmw offers a 3-year or 36,000-mile maintenance plan that covers all factory-recommended maintenance for the vehicle.
  • Mercedes-benz star service: Mercedes-benz offers several maintenance plans that cover different levels of service, from basic maintenance to more comprehensive coverage. These plans can be purchased for up to 5 years or 75,000 miles.

Each of these plans has its own unique features and benefits, so it’s important to carefully compare them to determine which is the best fit for your vehicle and your budget.

Understanding Service Plans

Definition And Details Of Service Plans

A service plan is a scheduled maintenance plan for your car, where you pay a fee to have your car serviced at regular intervals. In most cases, these intervals are every 6-12 months, but they may vary from one plan to another.

The idea behind a service plan is to help you budget for your car maintenance costs and to make sure that your vehicle is serviced by professionals, using genuine parts and up-to-date diagnostic equipment.

Here are some essential details to keep in mind about service plans:

  • Service periods are usually time or mileage-based. You will need to service your vehicle either after a certain number of kilometres or a set period.
  • Service plans can be customized based on your specific needs and budget. For instance, some service plans cover labour costs only, while others cover both labour and parts.
  • Service plans are usually transferable between owners, which means that if you sell your vehicle, the new owner can take over the plan as well.
  • Service plans can vary from one car manufacturer to another.

Coverage And Benefits Of Service Plans

Service plans typically cover all the standard maintenance tasks needed to keep your car running smoothly and efficiently. Here are some common tasks that are typically covered under a service plan:

  • Oil and filter changes
  • Brake service and inspection
  • Tire rotations and replacement
  • Cooling system maintenance
  • Electrical system inspection and maintenance
  • Engine tuning and diagnosis
  • Transmission service

The benefits of having a service plan include:

  • Predictable and manageable monthly payments that help you budget for your car maintenance expenses.
  • Peace of mind knowing that your vehicle is being serviced by professionals using genuine parts and up-to-date diagnostic equipment.
  • Minimizing the risk of major, costly repairs down the road.
  • Increased resale value as potential buyers are drawn to cars with a documented service history.

Factors To Consider When Choosing A Service Plan

When choosing a service plan, there are several factors to consider. Here are the top considerations:

  • The age of your vehicle: If you own a new car, you may want to consider a manufacturer’s service plan, as this will provide you with optimal coverage and peace of mind. If your vehicle is older, you may want to consider an aftermarket service plan to save on costs.
  • Driving habits and conditions: If you drive your vehicle regularly, you may want to consider a higher-mileage service plan. If you live in an area with harsh weather conditions, such as extreme heat or cold, you may want to consider a more comprehensive service plan that covers critical components such as your car’s battery, belts, and hoses.
  • Your budget: Service plans can range in cost, so it’s essential to choose a plan that fits within your budget while providing adequate coverage.

Example Of Popular Service Plans In The Market

Here are three examples of some of the most popular service plans available:

  • Manufacturer’s service plan: This plan is offered by your vehicle’s manufacturer and includes comprehensive scheduled maintenance, covering all servicing requirements for a set period or mileage. For example, mercedes-benz offers a variety of service plans which cover either up to three years or 45,000km, whichever comes first.
  • Aftermarket service plan: These plans are offered by third-party providers and typically cover servicing requirements for an extended period. For example, motorhappy offers service plans that can cover your vehicle maintenance needs for up to seven years.
  • Dealership service plan: Most reputable dealerships offer their own service plans which can be customized to provide added benefits such as 24-hour roadside assistance, and even warranties. For example, bmw offers a range of service plans, depending on the customer’s requirements.

When choosing a service plan, it’s essential to choose a plan that is suited to your specific needs based on factors such as your vehicle’s age, usage and driving conditions, and your budget. By doing so, you can ensure that your vehicle is always in top working order, making your investment in your car worthwhile.

Comparing Car Maintenance Plans To Service Plans

Costs, Performance, And Maintenance: A Closer Comparison

Every car owner knows that car maintenance and service plans are essential to ensure their vehicle’s durability and longevity. However, many people often confuse these two plans. So, what’s the difference between car maintenance plans and service plans?

In-depth comparison of the two plans in terms of benefits, costs, and coverage:

Car maintenance plans:

  • Usually in the form of a subscription that covers the cost of routine maintenance, such as oil changes, brake pad replacements, and tire rotations
  • Can cost anywhere from $100 to $500 a year
  • Typically covers only basic services and parts
  • Benefits include saving money by catching smaller issues before they become larger and more expensive to repair
  • Provides routine maintenance without the need for additional payment, which gives peace of mind and convenience to the car owner

Service plans:

  • Often purchased when the car is still new and under warranty and provide more comprehensive coverage than maintenance plans
  • Services can include repairs, replacements, and maintenance services
  • Costs vary depending on the contract terms, but can often exceed $1,000 a year
  • Usually cover all parts and labor costs, including wear and tear
  • Benefits include comprehensive coverage that can prevent unexpected expenses, peace of mind, and convenience by having everything covered in one payment

Pros and cons of each plan:

Car maintenance plans:


  • Covers basic routine maintenance
  • Cheaper than service plans
  • Provides convenience and peace of mind that the car is receiving regular maintenance


  • Does not cover more extensive repairs or replacements
  • Limited coverage, only covering basic services and parts

Service plans:


  • Comprehensive coverage that can include all repairs, replacements, and maintenance
  • Can save money in the long run by avoiding high repair costs
  • Warranty protection


  • Expensive, can cost over $1,000 a year
  • May duplicate services if you own a maintenance plan
  • Contracts may include many restrictions and limitations on covered services and parts.

Case studies of real-life scenarios to illustrate the comparison:

Case Study 1: Car Maintenance Plan

  • Lisa owns a 2015 toyota corolla that she uses for commuting to work daily
  • She subscribes to a car maintenance plan that costs her $300 a year
  • Lisa gets regular oil changes, tire rotations, and brake pad replacements
  • The plan covers basic things, and lisa only needs to pay when she needs additional services

Case Study 2: Service Plan

  • John buys a brand-new mercedes-benz, and the dealership offers him a new car service plan for $2200 a year for five years
  • The service plan covers all repairs, replacements, and maintenance costs, including wear and tear
  • Three years later, the car’s transmission failed, which would have cost nearly $5000 if he didn’t have the service plan
  • John saved money by not paying out of pocket, and the repair was covered by the warranty

Choosing between car maintenance plans and service plans depends on several factors, including the age, model, and usage of the vehicle and the car owner’s budget. A car maintenance plan is suitable for those looking for basic routine maintenance at an affordable cost, while a service plan is more comprehensive, more expensive, and provides the convenience of covering all expenses in one payment.

Ultimately, it’s up to each car owner to decide what’s best for them and their car.

Choosing The Right Plan For You

Car maintenance plan vs service plan: which is better for you?

Owning a car comes with a lot of responsibilities, including regular maintenance and servicing. Choosing between a car maintenance plan and a service plan can be confusing for many car owners. Each plan has its pros and cons, and it’s important to consider your needs and budget when making a decision.

In this post, we will explain the differences between the two plans and how to choose the best one for you.

Tips And Factors To Consider When Making A Decision

Here are some essential tips and factors to consider when deciding between a car maintenance plan and a service plan:

  • Budget: Consider your budget and the amount you’re willing to spend on maintaining your car.
  • Mileage: Determine how many miles you drive each year. If you drive a lot, a service plan may be a better option.
  • Age of your car: Consider the age of your car. If your car is still relatively new, a maintenance plan may be sufficient.
  • Type of car: The type of car you own should also be taken into account. Some cars require more maintenance than others.
  • Maintenance needs: Review the maintenance needs of your car, including oil changes, brake pad replacements, and tire rotations. Estimate how often you will need to perform these services.

Comparison Checklist To Help You Make A Decision

Here is a comparison checklist to help you decide between a car maintenance plan and a service plan:

Maintenance plan:

  • Covers basic maintenance needs, such as oil changes, fluid checks, and tire rotations.
  • Can be less expensive than a service plan.
  • Is typically recommended for newer cars.

Service plan:

  • Covers more extensive repairs and maintenance, such as brake pad replacements and engine tune-ups.
  • Can be more expensive than a maintenance plan.
  • Is recommended for older cars or cars with high mileage.

Making A Wise Decision: How To Choose The Best Plan For Your Car

When deciding between a car maintenance plan and a service plan, it’s essential to consider your budget, car’s mileage, age, type, and maintenance needs. Look at each plan’s advantages and disadvantages, and determine which one suits your needs best. Keep in mind that regular maintenance and servicing are vital to ensure your car’s longevity, reliability and maintaining its value.

Consider your lifestyle, the local weather conditions, and your driving habits to make the best decision for you and your car.

Choosing the right car maintenance plan or service plan can help you save money, and ensure your car runs smoothly. We hope this guide has helped you make an informed decision about which plan is best for you. Remember to stay on top of the maintenance of your car and protect your investment.

Frequently Asked Questions On Car Maintenance Plan Vs Service Plan

What Is A Car Maintenance Plan?

A car maintenance plan is a scheduled set of services that helps keep your car in top condition. It includes regular maintenance tasks such as oil changes, fluid level checks, and tire rotations.

What Is A Service Plan For A Car?

A service plan is an agreement you make with a dealership or service centre to perform maintenance and repairs on your car. It typically covers parts and labour for a set period of time or mileage.

What Is The Difference Between A Car Maintenance Plan And A Service Plan?

A car maintenance plan is a scheduled set of tasks to maintain your car’s condition, while a service plan is an agreement that covers parts and labour for a set time or mileage. A maintenance plan ensures your car is in good condition, while a service plan provides financial protection for repairs.

Is A Car Maintenance Plan Worth It?

Yes, a car maintenance plan is worth it if you want to extend the life of your car and reduce the likelihood of expensive repairs. It may also increase the resale value of your car.

What Is Included In A Typical Car Maintenance Plan?

A typical car maintenance plan usually includes oil changes, filter replacements, fluid level checks, brake inspections, and tire rotations. It’s important to check with the provider for specific details as coverage may vary.

Can You Purchase A Car Maintenance Plan After Buying A Car?

Yes, you can purchase a car maintenance plan after buying a car, but it’s often cheaper to purchase it with your new car. It’s important to weigh the cost of a plan against the potential savings on maintenance and repairs.


As you can see, both car maintenance plans and service plans have their own benefits and drawbacks. The choice between the two ultimately depends on your personal preferences and needs. However, it is important to remember that neglecting regular maintenance and repairs can lead to more costly expenses down the road.

Whether you decide on a car maintenance plan or a service plan, be sure to choose a reputable provider and understand the terms of your agreement. Maintaining a healthy car is crucial for safety, performance, and longevity. By investing in a plan that fits your lifestyle and budget, you can give yourself peace of mind and ensure that your vehicle stays in top condition.

Thank you for reading, and happy driving!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

is it necessary to polish a car before waxing

Previous Post

Is It Necessary to Polish a Car before Waxing: Expert Opinion.

Next Post

Car Maintenance at 100 000 Miles: Top Tips for Keeping Your Vehicle Running Smoothly.

car maintenance at 100 000 miles